Legal Insights — EN

How Are Signature and Identity Disputes in Company Share Transfers Examined?

A disputed signature or identity requires review of the transfer, notarial file, corporate resolutions and records, with separate assessment of remedies and protection.
Document folder, pen and seal on a desk overlooking Istanbul

If you believe your company shares were transferred without your consent using a disputed signature, identity details or authority document, first identify the documents behind the transaction and how the records changed. An allegation that your identity was used to register you as a shareholder also requires identification of the documents behind that entry. The review considers both ownership of the shares and the particular document whose authenticity is disputed. The appropriate application depends on the company type, the document and any existing proceedings or further-transfer risk.

Identify the Shares and Disputed Transaction

Transfers of limited liability company shares and joint stock company shares follow different requirements. For a limited liability company, the written transfer document, certification of signatures by a notary and any required general meeting approval are examined separately. For a joint stock company, whether shares are certificated, registered or bearer, and the delivery, approval and recording arrangements matter. A share-ledger entry, trade registry notice and transfer agreement are different records.

Prepare a short chronology identifying which shares allegedly passed, when and to whom. State the record through which you learned of the transaction and the document supplied to you. Any alleged payment is also examined; a payment record alone does not establish the authenticity of a signature or authority.

Preserve Originals and Comparison Records

  • The transfer agreement, schedules and any power of attorney.
  • The notary, transaction date and journal number, with file details concerning identity and authority checks.
  • The general meeting or board resolution, share ledger and relevant registry records.
  • Documents containing suitable comparison signatures from the relevant period.
  • Payment records, correspondence and evidence of when you learned of the transaction.

If you have only a photograph or scan, identify where the original is held. Preserve files without altering them and request records lawfully. Where evidence may be lost or become substantially harder to establish, court preservation of evidence and other protective steps may be considered if their conditions are met.

The Document Type Affects the Procedure

The Code of Civil Procedure treats denial of a signature on a private instrument differently from an allegation of forged writing or signature in an official instrument. For the latter, Article 208(4) requires a separate action also naming the person who gave the document its official character. If necessary, the judge hearing the main case sets a strict two-week deadline for the party disputing the writing or signature to bring that separate action. This period depends on an order in the particular case. Identify the notarial act and the precise part being challenged.

The examination does not necessarily begin with an expert report in every case. The court’s statutory sequence and available comparison documents matter. The effect of the allegation on use of the document also depends on whether the instrument is private or official. Provide any existing pleadings, service documents and interim orders so that the appropriate procedure can be assessed.

Separate the Claim from Interim Protection

Determining share ownership, seeking relief concerning company records and a criminal investigation pursue different outcomes. A criminal complaint does not itself satisfy every requirement for relief concerning company records. The form of proceedings, parties and deadlines are identified from the documents.

Identify any imminent sale or general meeting and provide its supporting record. Protection for the particular shares requires a separate assessment. The guides on injunctions against share transfers, proving AŞ shareholding and unrecorded Ltd share transfers address related questions. For a company and shareholding file review, scope and fees are agreed in writing before work starts.

Legal bases: Turkish Commercial Code; Code of Civil Procedure.