I Sold Property Far Below Its Value: How Is Exploitation Assessed?

Real Estate
A genuine sale of property at a price far below its value may call for assessment of exploitation involving gross disparity under Article 28 of the Turkish Code of Obligations. A clear imbalance between reciprocal performances must be examined together with exploitation of the seller's distress, thoughtlessness or inexperience. A price difference, age or later regret alone is not enough.
The Genuine Transaction and Value at the Time
First establish the transaction actually agreed and price actually paid. Read the official deed, bank transfers, any alleged cash payments, assumed debts and other performances together. Compare the property's legal and physical condition at the transaction date rather than setting today's value directly against a historical sale price.
Shared ownership, retained use, mortgages, tenancy, buildings, zoning and other burdens may affect that comparison. A valuation should explain these features and the relevant date. Do not assume a fixed percentage threshold applicable to every case.
The Seller's Situation and the Buyer's Exploitation
A distress allegation requires the concrete need and conditions at the time of sale. Records of debts falling due, payment pressure or another compelling circumstance can be assessed alongside negotiations and the chronology. For inexperience or thoughtlessness, explain the person's position in this particular transaction and how the decision was formed instead of relying on a general description.
How the buyer knew of and exploited that situation is a separate question. Messages, offers, price discussions, direct witness knowledge and transaction preparations may show the connection. A seller's need does not itself prove exploitation by the buyer. Include the other party's explanations about value, payment and negotiation conditions as well.
Distinguish the Two Remedies
Depending on the circumstances, Article 28 allows the injured party either to notify the other party that they are not bound and seek return of their performance, or to remain bound and seek removal of the disparity. Undoing the sale and continuing it with an adjustment are different remedies. Repayment of the price, registered title, parties and later acquisitions must be considered with the route chosen.
If the property has since been transferred, examine the present owner and transfer chain separately. An allegation concerning the first sale should not assume that every later transaction automatically falls away.
When Do the One-Year and Five-Year Periods Start?
The right may be exercised within one year after discovering the thoughtlessness or inexperience, or after the distress ends, and in any event within five years after the contract was formed. These starting events are different. Record the transaction date, discovery and the event ending distress separately, with supporting documents. Whether another step taken is sufficient to exercise this right requires assessment in the particular matter.
Documents for Review
- The official sale deed, agreements and current and earlier title records.
- Bank records, receipts and correspondence showing the actual price and all performances.
- Valuation and comparison evidence addressing the property's features at the transaction date.
- Available documents showing the special circumstances, the buyer's knowledge and negotiations.
- Discovery or the end of distress, and a short list of events each witness knows directly.
An apparent sale concealing a gift raises sham-transaction issues; misinformation or threats may concern defective consent; an heir's allegation of evading inheritance rights has its own requirements. The same price evidence may be relevant to different legal grounds. The suitable basis follows the seller's actual account and the documents.